Journey to the Lands of the Ancestors
A travel blog by Dhammadipa for the MA in Art History and the Preservation of Buddhist Heritage
Page 1 of 3
Image: Dhammadipa
About This Travel Blog
This travel journal is part of a course in Buddhist Heritage. It describes a journey that I took together with the teachers and students of The Courtauld MA program of 2023 - 2024. It is best viewed on a laptop, rather than on a phone. - DD
Trip to China from Monday, May 6 through Thursday, May 16, 2024
Day 1: May 6 - Beijing
Having walked down the broad boulevard lit by the marketing of global corporate brands, we arrive at a quiet teahouse. The waitress takes us upstairs to a room full of light woods, grass mats, and greenery. It smells of green tea. Before long, she brings us steaming teapots and small plates of pistachios. We don’t know it yet, but this juxtaposition of the modern and the timeless will weave its way through the whole of our stay in China.
Dr. Guolong Lai, a Professor of Chinese art and archaeology, brings out his laptop. The care of heritage sites and objects began centuries ago in Song Dynasty (960 – 1279 CE) China, he explains, when heritage was primarily valued on the basis of esthetics, whether a thing was considered beautiful or not. However, following education reform in the early 1900s and a period of Western exploitation of archaeological sites, heritage became an industry and its scientific value became the predominant concern. Later, China was swept by the mid-century international movement toward government ownership of heritage, whether above or below ground. Laws were implemented to prevent the movement of valuable objects, including Buddhist artifacts, to overseas collections. Then, as the pressure to increase financial prosperity grew and China sought to advance its position in the global marketplace, the economic value of heritage became the predominant measure. Indeed, it is this last shift that creates government support for heritage tourism, and makes it possible for travelers like us to see firsthand the treasures of China’s past.
Our group has flown in from several countries - Korea, Japan, the UK and from within China - and gathered here in Beijing to study Buddhist heritage together. We are students and teachers of Buddhist art and conservation who have come to experience Buddhism as it has been uniquely expressed here over more than 1,700 years.
Above: These are statues of a Buddha in abhaya mudra (gesture of fearlessness) and two bodhisattvas at Maijishan.
White pagoda of Behei Park, Beijing. Detail of a painting in the collection of the China Academy of Cultural Heritage. Artist unknown.
Dr. Guolong Lai, a Professor of Chinese art and archaeology speaks to the group.
Day 2: May 7 - Beijing
On a warm, sunny spring morning, we move among the many people overflowing the bustling streets at the heart of Beijing. The streets are filled with the sounds of city traffic. Shortly we arrive at the Palace Museum, a large public art institution that is housed within the Forbidden City. Until 1925, it was the residence of Chinese Emperors but now it teams every day with thousands of visitors from around the globe. Courtauld Professor Lori Wong has been in contact with her friend, Lei Yong, Deputy Director of the Conservation Department. He takes us on a “behind the scenes” tour during which we meet with a number of conservation scientists, each with a particular area of expertise. Some work on metal objects, some work on textiles, others on clocks or painting reproductions, and all of them have years of formal education and apprenticeship in their field. They describe their philosophy as one of “maintaining the intangible heritage” by repairing and restoring objects according to traditional and modern methods. This practice stands in contrast to most European conservators’ philosophy of “minimal intervention.”
They proudly show us their current projects, mentioning that one object may take up to three years to repair. Yong is also excited to share that the newest area is dedicated to the preservation of thangkas. Thangkas are the complex, colorful paintings of esoteric or tantric Buddhism. In this area the women painstakingly attend to both the fabric and the paper on which the thangkas are painted. As she speaks, the conservation scientist points to a thangka hanging on the wall, and I am dismayed when she later opens a drawer containing the original object. What is on the wall is only a digital reproduction, placed there for planning purposes.
As the tour continues, we are invited to a bountiful lunch with the Director of the Palace Museum, Wang Xudong, who spent many years in conservation at Dunhuang Academy, where he also met Lori. He explains that there are more than 2,000 Buddhist objects in the Museum’s collection and encourages us to see them all. That will have to wait for another trip, though, as we have other places to be.
Our next stop is a small building called “Juanqin zhai,” or “The Studio of Exhaustion After Diligent Service.” It was a project of Emperor Qianlong in 1772. That is, four years before the United States would declare its independence from England, Qianlong, the fourth Emperor in his Dynasty, was considering retiring from a reign that began in 1735. The building has been painstakingly conserved. Wall paintings depicting wisteria blossoms and spotted bamboo appear as if new, gracing all the walls and the entire ceiling. Unfortunately, like many conservation sites that are highly valued, no photos are permitted and the building is closed to the public in order to prevent damage from over-tourism. Yet who are saving it for? Will it not deteriorate again even though no one is there to see it?
Yangxing dian, Hall of Spiritual Cultivation, Palace Museum. Image: Dhammadipa
Director Xudong (blue jacket) hosts our group for lunch at the canteen for employees of the Palace Museum.
Roses at the Palace Museum.
Song Dynasty Avalokiteshavara in the collection of the National Museum of China.
Ding with rams heads in the collection of the National Mueseum of China.
Jade death suit in the collection of the National Mueseum of China.
Fragments of stone wall railing inscribed with Buddhist text in the collection of the National Museum of China.
3d printed replica of a cave wall from Bingling cave grottoes in the collection of the National Museum of China.
Day 3: May 8 - Beijing
I awaken and meditate, as usual. It is too early to go down to breakfast, so I walk over to the window where I can see the white pagoda rising among the trees and buildings of Beijing. The evidence of religion is here, right in the midst of daily life, but it is hard to tell how people really feel about it.
After breakfast, we join the many commuters on the subway as we travel to the National Museum of China. Here, in Beijing, everyone must pass their personal items through the x-ray machines and walk through a metal detector just to get to the train platform. I see a small boy being passed over with a wand. What is it like for him?
The museum sits alongside Tiananmen Square and the security there is quite intense. Even with our museum guide present, we must present our identification to an armed guard to enter the area. Standing at the door of the museum, waiting to be escorted in where we will again pass our personal items through an x-ray machine, we are passed by a group of cadets marching in formation.
The National Museum of China is an enormous structure, and the docent leads us up several floors to the main exhibition hall. It is filled to the brim with visitors and people jostle one another to get a view of the art. Here, the displays tell of the archaeological finds that have been made in Beijing. They provide evidence of a matriarchal society in this area as far back as 7,000 years ago, whose members cooked food, sewed with needles, and wore jewelry. Over thousands of years, society progressed, and animals were domesticated. Villages were identified by the fact that all the doors of the huts faced a central space. During the Shang Dynasty, from 1600 to 1100 BCE, bronze three- or four-footed vessels called “dings” were produced to contain food, wine, or ritual offerings. These objects are quite ornate and demonstrate sophisticated metalworking methods. For some time, humans and animals were sacrificed, in the hopes of gaining protection for family members. By the time of the reign of the Han Dynasty, 202 BCE to 220 CE, that practice had stopped and elaborate tombs developed. The wealthy might be encased in jade burial suits stitched together with gold or silver thread. At this time, tombs also contained ceramic statues of soldiers and horses, all thought to assist the deceased in the afterlife.
It is during the latter part of the Han Dynasty that Buddhism was introduced to China. A broken stone bearing a Buddhist inscription in the Central Asian language of Kharosthi provides evidence from as early as the 2nd century CE. Also on this floor we encounter a life-size 3D printed replica of cave sculpture from the Bingling Grottoes, 1,500 km to the southwest of Beijing. At about 2 meters wide by 1.5 meters tall, it is a testament to Chinese conservators’ and curators’ skillful use of contemporary technology to enable its culture to be shared widely and in new ways. Our guide describes the cave grottoes as forms of “promotion” of Buddhism but I think of them as places of devotional expression.
Finally, we have 15 minutes to go downstairs to a hall filled with Buddhist statuary. It is nearly empty. The centerpiece of this exhibit is a stunningly beautiful Song Dynasty wooden statue of “Guan Yin,” known in Sanskrit as “Avalokiteshvara.” This piece was created between 960 and 1279 CE, and was purchased from a private collector as recently as 2005. It would be interesting to study what happened in the intervening years. One way to understand her name is the “One Who Looks Down [from above]” and the object’s placement on a raised platform enables us to experience her gentle, downward gaze. Another way to understand the name is the “One Who Hears the Cries of the World,” and therefore she is depicted in “lalitasana” or the “pose of relaxation” from which she can easily move to respond to what she hears. Her elaborate hairstyle and jewelry confirm that she is a “bodhisattva,” an awakening being, and not a “Buddha,” or fully awakened being who eschews all adornment (except in tantric Buddhist art) and typically has an “ushnisha,” a protrusion on the head.
Then we head over to the China Academy for Cultural Heritage where Courtauld alumna Li Na works in conservation science. This organization was established in 1935, initially only consulting with and advising on cultural heritage projects in Beijing. Now they have expanded to become national and international in scope, and they undertake and complete projects of their own, such as a stupa restoration recently completed in collaboration with the government of Mongolia. Over the years they have collaborated with Historic England, Italian conservators, and with the governments of Nepal and Uzbekistan. At CACH, paper conservators are working on large scale sutra projects. This very detailed work involves taking apart ancient sutra rolls or palm leaf manuscripts and then carefully applying them to specialized papers in such a way as to recreate a legible document, leaving appropriate spaces where material is missing. This is tremendously helpful to those who study these texts and the scripts in which they are written.
*** scroll down to find the link to the next page ***
Beijing Highlights
Click here to continue the journey. <— link to the next page